What the ERA Campaign Can Learn from the LGBT Movement

While the media and citizens are celebrating the lightning speed of the accomplishments of the LGBT Movement the ERA Campaign has a lot to gain by noting some key elements which contributed to this historically high-speed success.  Since I have walked both these lanes of the social justice movement for 40 years and in the last 10 come to the reckoning that all roads of oppression intersect, I have a few experienced insights I want to share.        

As I have heard and repeated so many times, social movements take over 150 years, the LGBT Movement broke through that barrier.  They really put their heads down and conquered the internet allowing them to create a true sense of urgency.  It has cut broadcast time, organizing effort and fundraising immeasurably.  However in the ERA campaign, many of our strongest supporters do not use facebook, youtube or Twitter.  Even more of an obstacle is that many pro-ERA people do not regularly use email which leaves them not only out of the information stream entirely but, even worse, thinking there is no ERA interest whatsoever.  This is a serious problem which carries a residual toxin of intergenerational division. In the future this will not be a problem, as in 10 years everyone will be using electronic communication but there is a lot of untapped strength and artificial unraveling right now hidden in the midst of this cultural shift. 

Second, LGBT mobilized internally on all cylinders; from liberal bureaucrats to street radicals - every level pushed the status quo with focus on particular issues.  Within the movement there was internal criticism about civil disobedience, arrest actions, marches, conferences all the way to loud disapproval of those orgs that wanted to slow down and build patient alliances with the White House.  All that rabble rousing collectively created energy.  

Third, the LGBT movement began paying attention and soliciting all avenues of support; corporations, members of Congress and the White House itself.  Relentless, sometimes illegal and sometimes elegant pressure, from Alonzo Mourning’s house to black tie dinners, the President was pressed with no end in sight.  It is well documented that his “evolution” was partially motivated by it. 

Fourth, they recollected their history which brought the movement heroes, gravitas, weight, pride.  It has had a tremendous effect.  Young people take pride in the Queens of Stonewall and the Daughters of Bilitis all the way to Lady Gaga and Lt Dan Choi.  Inspiring historic characters have been celebrated and movies made.  Layer upon layer, like the Names Quilt itself, have contributed to radical change-making.  History, from Stonewall to the White House Fence to hundreds of renown people coming out or announcing their advocacy, built an alliance and lineage.  

Fifth is the current day tragedies.  Terrible suicides and murders set hearts on fire but I would argue that every day that women are not in the US Constitution women and children die from inadequate wages, healthcare, loss of the comprehensive VAWA, too many things to list.  What is different is that LGBT brought issues into focus, connected dots and, though there was never agreement on how, there was always agreement on the goal.  

The ERA Campaign has so many things to our advantage; the ERA is already on the Democrat Party Platform, two strategies in play with bills in Congress (69, 21, 47, 39), stated support by members of Congress and the White House.  To our disadvantage we do not have singular focus, many of our women’s organizations do not dedicate any work on this issue.  2011, NWPC unanimously voted to have an ERA Liaison but does not have one, NOW does not have a lead solely dedicated to the ERA.  While it might be perceived as too thorny to take on because of different strategies, it is really quite easy – fully support them both - all as do Carolyn Maloney and Tammy Baldwin, authors of each. 

As a known champion of the ERA I am asked constantly, what is happening? Who is working it?  Why isn’t NOW making it front and center?  I think that the real question is why isn’t the entire country, which supports it by a margin of over 70%, on fire about this country advancing its position of women In leadership (ranking 72^nd globally) and constitutional inclusion.  While we invade other countries and insist on women quotas in elected seats and inclusive constitutions, USA merely writes her intention in a platform, on bills in every congress since 1948 and knows that we will never force the issue, that would be too messy.  Women haven’t stormed the White House Fence for the ERA since 1981.  We have not increased the number of women in Congress since then either. 

While I am not a fan of the phrase, War on Women, I would say their most effective weapon is they are certain nothing will actually guarantee women’s rights but full constitutional equality and that remains allusive, out of focus and sounds like some history lesson.  While women and liberation activists are busy trying to make every dollar = two, there is little time for such trivialities as the ERA.  I can say with total honesty, the LGBT movement never allowed such a notion to dissuade them. 

The LGBT movement had two pinpoint demands; repeal Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell and Marriage Equality.  The opponent showed the reach of his hand with the passage of Prop 8.  That was the tipping point and, even though it was only about California, the entire Queer Nation rallied and in less than a year, held a national march on Coming Out Day.  Maybe the fact that it was California, incorrectly deemed the most progressive state, combined with removing a right already exercised by 1,800 couples, set all engines on warp speed.  I ask, what could be more inciting than the litany of egregious attacks on US women, from family planning to wages to seniors to education, etc. the worst of it is we are being attacked by a Gatling gun, dispersing any vision we should be holding precisely.     

To try to do my part, I am posting entries from my 1982 diary every day for 37 days here.  I do feel a mission to make sure this time is not forgotten. Though we did not win the ERA at the time, some extraordinary women and men contributed to the unfolding of Gender Equality.  It was a proud time when we truly practiced ALL HANDS ON DECK. There were fasters and civil disobedience and grassroots and legislative and bureaucrats and orgs and clergy and unity. It is a very inspiring time. Women and girls today deserve to know about it.  The current day women's movement needs to know about the radiant activism that has occurred along this long arduous path to equality. What you are doing now is in direct lineage, it is cumulative, Equality is on the way.

Comments

[Melinda Tremaglio]

As usual, a very inspiring, thoughtful article. I love your passion and tenacity for the ERA and equality!

[Kamala]

Thank you, Zoe, for your incisive analysis and clarion call for unity and collaboration. And thank you, as ever, for keeping the torch burning for equality for everyone.
I would like permission to repost this article on the front page of http://eraeducationproject
love
Kamy

[Linda Perkins]

Zoe, this is an excellent, timely and very needed piece. I think you're correct the social media and technology can accelerate action, information and awareness of issues. I cringe when so many of my colleagues announce with great superiority that they don't use any type of social media and/or technology. It's as if it's beneath and "frivolous" . I had one colleague tell me she doesn't even have a cell phone. Okay, it's a free country. But, just like when people complain about the "junk" on tv -(I have a colleague who has no TV), you have choices for what you watch. There are many, many things I don't watch on TV but to condemn an entire medium because of some horrible and detrimental programming is wrong in my opinion. We just have to continue to bring the topic of the ERA up wherever we can and hopefully it will emerge again. I think many people don't think we need the ERA becasue they falsely think that women's legal rights have been taken care of. I applaud your lifelong commitment to this issue.

[Erin]

Terrific. I am sharing this.